Measurement Forum Archive

Read-only historical archive of measure.infopop.cc

rrTC 2016 agenda topic: Certifying tracks

#1 • 10/29/16 @ 11:19 AM
Should we take off the certificate “Track”. We are not in the business of certifying Tracks.
#2 • 10/29/16 @ 11:30 AM
You are correct. Then why have it on the certificate?
#3 • 10/29/16 @ 11:36 AM
Comment from Jeff John:

This question has always perplexed me. I've heard emotional responses that suggest a problem that does not exist! Nobody ever asked me to bring my total station and transit and do a complete licensed surveyor mapping of a track at a cost of $10,000 or more. That's not what we do. But, we do measure the length of road courses that may utilize part or all of a track. Some road races are entirely on the track. We can, we do, and we should continue to verify a track's length when needed since that IS what we do. The licensed surveyor is NOT going to do that. Leave it on.
#4 • 10/29/16 @ 11:44 AM
Yes, but does one know when to add 20cm or 30cm to the diameter.
#5 • 10/29/16 @ 11:50 AM
If a track is part of a road course that is being measured, we should measure that part the way that we always do.
But if someone asks us to do a stand-alone measurement of a track for certification, I don't think we should do that. Tracks are certified to a higher level of accuracy than our methods can measure. We are always free to measure and tell them we think it's accurate, but I don't think we should certify.
#6 • 10/29/16 @ 11:54 AM
Tracks with curbs are measured 30 cm from the outside edge of the curb.
Tracks measured and marked not to have a curb are measured 20 cm from the outer edge of the white line.
Cones can not be used to replace a curb for the entire track - only for short sections as with the high jump and javelin without making adjustments for the starting line(s)
We should not be certifying tracks. We do certify a course that uses part of a track. We do not have jurisdiction with events that are completely run on a track.
#7 • 10/29/16 @ 11:56 AM
good points
#8 • 10/29/16 @ 2:42 PM
Jeff posted in another Agenda thread that some road races are run entirely on a track. Hmmm. Then it is not really a 'road race'.

If it is run entirely on a track, we could measure a 'course'. We would certify the course, but not certify the track. Ideally, though, you would just do the math based on the length of the shortest lane you are allowed to use.
#9 • 10/29/16 @ 7:13 PM
I think it's a bit rash to throw out the track language. I've certified quite a few over the years--for the purpose of long distance races on the track. (I think someone mentioned that this could apply to races of at least 3000 meters?).

We probably need to make it clear that we are NOT talking about confirming all the lines on the track, just the overall length. Also, if the track owner/operator can locate the original certificate from the surveyors who laid it out, that would be the best documentation.
#10 • 10/29/16 @ 9:33 PM
Bob, I don't know how you make that clear. If someone sees that the USATF has certified a track, they will think everything about the track is correct.
#11 • 10/30/16 @ 6:26 PM
I think it can be clearly and prominently stated. But also I don't think we should throw out the possibility of checking on a course to be used in, say, a one hour run, just because some folks are going to misinterpret it.

I know measurers have done this for decades (check the overall distance of a track-- i.e. lane one). I'm not clear at what point, or why, folks seem to be stating that "we don't certify tracks".
#12 • 10/30/16 @ 7:54 PM
I will repeat, we (RRTC) do not have the authority to say that a running track is USATF Certified. In fact, there is no such thing as a USATF Certified Track. The term "certified tracks" is used by two groups: 1. Track builders who states that a track they built is certified by them. This is required by the institution that hire the builder for legal purposes. Some sports federations, NCAA and high school also recognize this certification. 2. The other is IAAF Certification - which is required for performances to be recognized for qualifying for Olympic Games, World Championships, and World Records. Both types of Certification requires measurement techniques beyond the capabilities of most road course measurers.
#13 • 10/31/16 @ 6:52 AM
I agree with David: We are repeating this issue. And I must concur with the mantra: We do not "certify tracks!"

But, it is also a fact that we can certify a course run entirely on a track and we are effectively the only ones who can and will do that. It is a valuable service and it would be a shame if the world were to lose that service due to unfounded fear of someone else's potential misunderstanding or intentional fraud.

Unless legal asserts that the liability risk is too great then we should try to come to an understanding on this issue.

I do not have any great qualms about removing the "track" check box on the cert. My preference is to keep it. Storing this information makes is easier, for example, for new measurers to locate track measurement examples and study how track measurements can and have been made.

What I must strongly disagree with is effectively ordering our measurers to refuse a track measurement.

My Vice Chair, Justin Kuo, is wary of track measures too. He offered a good solution last year. When I needed to certify a track course he required a bold disclaimer on the map to make very clear what we were doing and what we were not doing. That's a good idea.

Here's an example: http://www.usatf.org/events/co...p?courseID=NY15029JJ

Its not perfect, but you get the idea. Make it very clear, in a prominent spot, what we are and are not doing.

My rationale for keeping the track check box: We are not "certifying the track" any more than we are "certifying the road" when we check the "road" check box. This is valuable information -- let's not lose or hide it.

After all... We're not in the business of certifying roads either!

JJ
#14 • 10/31/16 @ 7:39 AM
No, we can not certify a course that is run entirely on a track - that is a "track" race. We certify "road" races.
I just got off the phone with Duffy Mahoney.
Duffy for those of you that don't know is one of the most respected administrators of USATF. he is the Director of High Performance as well as a private consultant for track planning and construction. He confirmed that USATF only recognizes the two entities I previously mentioned that can "certify" the distance of a track for a track event (not road race) - the certificate from the builder/stripper and the IAAF.
#15 • 10/31/16 @ 7:44 AM
Let me add that a licensed surveyor using a "total station" can also certify a track as long as he follows the measurement requirements.
The bike method is not acceptable for track certification...period!
#16 • 10/31/16 @ 6:47 PM
I like Jeff's example and the disclaimer language. And I agree that we are the most likely folks to actually agree to check track distance for distance running purposes.

I don't understand David's bicycle comment as I didn't think anyone would try using a bike to measure a track. Well maybe there are some who would.

David, since we have been doing these measurements for decades (see old discussions in Measurement News, Bob Baumel's paper on how to measure a track, etc), are you saying we were wrong to do that? Or that it was incorrect to "certify" the tracks as we did? Or is this a recent rule that you are speaking of?
#17 • 10/31/16 @ 8:27 PM
I am not speaking for David, but I agree, as I stated above - if an event is run entirely on a track, it is a track event, and not a road race. Each lane of a track is a known length (even if you have to pull a tape and do math). No need to ride a bike on the track.

If an event uses the track for a small portion of the event, then yes, measure with a bike (much faster than a tape). This would qualify as a road race, as the majority of the course is on roads.
#18 • 10/31/16 @ 8:39 PM
Duane, I agree. This means there is a simple solution.

We take off track on the certificate!!!!
#19 • 10/31/16 @ 8:47 PM
I don't like that. Can we get the history understood first? (Why "track" is on the form, etc)
#20 • 10/31/16 @ 11:47 PM
Don't know what. Maybe Bob Baumel or David Katz could answer that.

However, my guess would be someone(probably Bob)devise a way to measure a track. The point is we shouldn't issue track certificates. Hence, I say the method we have online is good and it should be for a road race period..
#21 • 11/1/16 @ 2:21 AM
To reply to Bob, in the past few years both USATF and the IAAF have become more stringent in accepting performance for athletic events where athletes are trying to qualify for the World Championships, Olympic Games and setting World Records. There have been many bogus performances from questionable facilities. The focus has not been on road races but more on tracks(and field).
I have not doubt that some of measurers are very capable of determining the total length of a track using the proper techniques and equipment but there is a great deal more that falls under the "Certification" of a track. Track certification by the two entities mentioned in a previous post not only requires the distance of the oval, but all of the starting lines, the lanes widths, break lines, relay zones, etc. It also has requirements for the inclination of the track - inwards and overall! And all of the field event venues have their own requirements as well. Are we prepared to do this?
If the RRTC issued a "USATF Certificate" for a track it would be misleading.
#22 • 11/1/16 @ 4:11 AM
Having mot measured a track, but having measured sections of tracks as part of a road race, I feel qualified to chime in. It seems that there are about a dozen USATF certified track courses, some very recent. Clearly the certifiers are not standard in their requirements. That is one thing that could be fixed.
Another is the name of the category on the certificate. "Track" could be changed to "Track Course" or the like. David's point is valid that there is much more to "certifying" a track than almost all measurers are capable of.
Since there are races held entirely on tracks that are not part of track meets, there should be some way the RRTC can accommodate these courses.
I guess that means I vote for changing the name of the "Track" category to something that indicates the track measurement to road measurement standards (Track Course) and requiring a standard method of measurement and disclaimer. The Vice Chairs and Registrar can certainly check and enforce the method of measurement and disclaimer if the certifiers can't. Ignoring or prohibiting the measurement of courses on tracks doesn't seem to be a good approach.
#23 • 11/1/16 @ 4:18 AM
Tracks present another difficult issue that Gene touched on briefly. Do we assume there will be a curb or not? You might think this is a trivial difference, but it is not. The difference in length between using 20cm or 30cm is 0.628 meters, which is 0.157% of the length. That's 1.57xSCPF, or more than twice the allowable tolerance between two measurements. If we do decide to continue to provide a track checkbox, should we say there are two possible distances? 400m if there is a curb and 399.372m if not?

Also, the method we have accepted for measuring tracks assumes that the turns are both circular, and both with the same radius. As I've said before, if we are going to assume that, we might as well just assume the track is 400m long.

I understand the need that some RDs have for making sure a track they are using for a mile race, or a 1-hour run, is actually a 400m track (and not a 440y track?). But I think that can be done by a measurer who tells them their measurement came out very close to 400m, and the track is PROBABLY a certified 400m track. Leave the USATF out of it.
#24 • 11/1/16 @ 5:09 AM
If an American age-group record for the 1-hour run is set on a track we have certified, will USATF accept it? That would certainly be the expectation of an RD who has a piece of paper in his hand that says the track is USATF certified.
#25 • 11/1/16 @ 5:24 AM
Mark brings up another important point - not all tracks have a uniform radius. Many have a double radius which prohibits the use of the simple measurement technique previously outlined.
#26 • 11/1/16 @ 5:33 AM
If we decide not to issue certificates for tracks, which I feel should be the case. Then what do we do with all those already issued?
#27 • 11/1/16 @ 5:51 AM
I measured a course where the first and last 300+ meters were on a track. Since most schools don't like wheeled vehicles on their track, I taped from the 300m mark to a point off the track surface, then rode the portion on the roads.
#28 • 11/1/16 @ 5:58 AM
Jim, this is not what we are talking about. I believe we are referring to races run entirely on a track.
#29 • 11/1/16 @ 6:04 AM
For LDR TRACK records to be processed and ratified I do not need a measurement certificate from RRTC. What is required is a certificate from the contractor stating the surveyor measured the track correct when it was constructed. No course/track validation/verification is required for a USATF LDR record to be ratified.
#30 • 11/1/16 @ 10:52 AM
Good luck with this, Andy. How many track owners/operators out there actually have such a certificate from the construction surveyor? I guess you must have *some* in your database.

I measured a track with an associate using Baumel's methodology a few years ago. The client wanted to establish how many laps would constitute a 2 mile run. We did a lot of steel tape work and careful calculations to show the client exactly where to start and finish, and how many laps and how far on the partial lap to get to exactly 2 miles. I have total confidence that this measurement is well within the limits of accuracy we rely on.

We did not think of ourselves as "certifying a track". We thought of ourselves as meticulously measuring a course, including the SCPF, which was to be run on a track. We included the 20 cm consideration and the proviso that the measured course was valid only if participants were restricted to the measured path - no different than a road course. So, in a sense, it mattered little or not at all what the actual measurement of the track itself might be. We did not use bikes, just tapes. We did not steel tape measure around the track multiple laps. Yet, given a very careful and exacting measurement of multiple parts of the track, including both curved portions, we feel certain that the course we detailed and mapped is every bit as accurate for a 2-mile race as any ever done on the road.
#31 • 11/1/16 @ 11:18 AM
Lyman, yes we might have done it correctly. However, we don't certify tracks as Katz has stated. There is more to it than just the distance as Katz has stated.

We only measure Road Races!
#32 • 11/1/16 @ 11:43 AM
If it were feasible to perform "licensed surveyor mapping" of many tracks, I am guessing that some non-trivial percentage of them would prove to be short or long by a non-trivial quantity. This difference would of course then be magnified, commensurate with the distance of the race conducted on the track.

Therefore, to convey a valid imprimatur of a particular race's accuracy, the RD would have to perform the necessary arithmetic to adjust for the difference based on the total advertised distance, and then make the concomitant adjustment to the Start and Finish lines.

Is this what actually happens for track events for which records are kept?

I am tempted to think that, for track races of, say 5000 meters and longer, riding a bike or using a calibrated wheel with a Counter for the full distance would probably yield a total course just as accurate as a survey/adjustment combination - at least in practice, if not in theory.

Thoughts?
#33 • 11/1/16 @ 1:43 PM
I don't understand what you want. Our certificate should not have track on it in my opinion.

I doubt what you say is true. The bike in my view will not be the best way to measure a track.

Andy Carr and David have a explained this well. Read it.
#34 • 11/2/16 @ 6:06 AM
In my entire measurement career I've only had occasion to measure a track course one time. It was a freebee for the local running clubs - and they really did appreciate it. They had created a road mile series and put one of the races on the track to add some spice.

I used the geometry technique we call the Baumel Method, but would have preferred to have also had an actual lap measure too. Like Jim Gerweck, I didn't want to offend too many people by bringing a bicycle onto the popular track.

We did eventually acquire the striper's documentation and my confidence was boosted by the remarkably good agreement in our lap lengths. But I do worry about the possibility of a track geometry anomaly possibly skewing the Baumel Method result.

Pete Riegel measured a track in 2010 primarily using a device called a Rolatape. I'd like to know about his methodology in that exercise -- I think he measured the full lap twice with the Rolatape and steel taped the straight-aways. He produced a very valuable document for the local running community based on that effort. In it he has provided calculated lengths for all eight running lanes. You can see it here:
http://www.usatf.org/events/co...p?courseID=OH10005PR
#35 • 11/2/16 @ 7:44 AM
Track measuring is very complicated.
Please check out the measurement report required by the IAAF. Click on the link and scroll down to the "Measurement Report"
https://www.iaaf.org/about-iaa...certification-system
I along with many of you don't like some of the policies of the IAAF (only requiring one measurement) but the requirements for track certification is very exacting.
Please check out the form.
#36 • 11/2/16 @ 8:03 AM
I apologize... this is going a little off topic, but I believe Lyman has a very interesting point. Road Running is a subset of Track & Field and we do care about and are involved in the sport.

I am not entirely comfortable with a for profit commercial entity assuring me that he did a good job of building or striping the track with no independent validation -- ever. Is that we have?

It is clear, and I appreciate Andy's polite statement that he "does not need" a certificate from RRTC. But what if a track, even though it can provide the engineer's, or surveyor's, or striper's certificate, is off. These guys are real good, they're professionals, they've signed an integrity oath, they're licensed, but they are also human. Humans make mistakes (I prove that every day!) How will we know?

This may be an area where RRTC can provide a clue that there may be a problem with a track that warrants a closer look by a qualified independent entity such as the PE or licensed land surveyor using IAAF methodology. I vehemently agree with David. We don't do that.

David Katz, and a few others, have proffered wonderful, logical, valid, persuasive arguments proving that the RRTC does not certify the track & field stadium. Unfortunately, the argument is almost pointless since that was never the question. I trust we all agree we don't do that, we don't want to do that, and we can't do that. Drop it! We are only offering to measure one parameter -- course distance, and our methodologies are known to be not sufficient for track record purposes.

And I think David is right... if you run a race on a track you're running a track race! As proof, I expect that we can not ratify a road race run on a track as the track confers some advantages over the road.

But that does not mean our service has no value to Track & Field.

Just for fun, I opened our database to see if Jordan was right. The very first track in the list of track courses measured by our people jumped out. It's a beautiful indoor track facility in Anchorage Alaska. Its advertised and used as a 6-lane 400 meter track. I presume that for record purposes it will have to be considered an outdoor track, but its in a dome. High School records have been set on it.

But, RRTC measurers Lee Barrett and Fred Wilson measured it and found the lane 1 length at 20cm from the inner edge to be 413.6 meters. Wow! That's a huge variance. Something is wrong. If the variance had been in the opposite direction then I think Andy would want to know about it if a record had been set on a track that was potentially 13 meters short, despite the striper's assurance. Who's gonna alert him?

I'd hate for Track & Field to lose this skill set that RRTC could continue to provide if not for the as yet unsupported fear that some unidentified 3rd party will misunderstand the very real limitations of our work.

JJ
#37 • 11/2/16 @ 8:18 AM
Yes that is a huge difference. However, who is to say the semi-circles are exactly the same at each. These guys may have assumed exactly that.

I trust the surveyor more than using our method Bob explained in the manual for measuring a track. I feel as David we don't certify tracks. There will be more to follow as to how we will handle this by the end of the week.
#38 • 11/3/16 @ 6:10 AM
FYI: Here's an interesting followup on the Anchorage indoor track mentioned above. Justin knew about it and shared some more of the story as to why our guys had to measure and why it was so far off the nominal 400 m distance.

Its expensive to operate a bubble dome facility and soccer is their bread and butter. The facility operators decided to sacrifice a chunk of the inner lane(s) to expand the infield for soccer. Ugh!

JJ
#39 • 11/3/16 @ 8:04 AM
Hey, Gene - do we certify tracks? Smiler
#40 • 11/3/16 @ 8:16 AM
Lyman,

In the past we did have a procedure that you followed to certify a track. However, it has come to light according to the IAAF we can't certify a track. This is done by a surveyor. We certify Road Races.


The simple simple answer is NO! By the middle of next week there will be a statement about this.
#41 • 11/3/16 @ 8:41 AM
quote:
Originally posted by Gene Newman:
I don't understand what you want. Our certificate should not have track on it in my opinion.
- or at leat I
I doubt what you say is true. The bike in my view will not be the best way to measure a track.

Andy Carr and David have a explained this well. Read it.


Did you read what I wrote, Gene?

Let's try to get past the idea that anyone here is advocating that we start certifying tracks for a moment - and see if there is anything worthwhile to discuss before anyone unilaterally shuts down this discussion. At the least, we may come to a better understanding of how and why we do what we do. Sound fair?

Seems to me we are saying that our measuring methods are fine for roads, but not adequate for tracks. To me, this implies that there may be some different standard for track measurement, separate and apart from the measuring instruments and the particular measuring protocol employed for any particular track. If we feel this is true, what is the reasoning for having two different standards? Are track races - assuming curbs are properly installed - something we just assume are inherently more accurate and/or valid than certified road races/courses? We see here there are at least two examples in which the tracks are way off.

Jeff's experience with the track he measured is similar to that of my experience with the track I measured. I cannot speak for Jeff, but I feel safe in speculating that Jeff and I both are connoting that our track measurements yielded differences between the advertised length of the track and our measurements that seem too large for a professional survey of the same track measurement to be anywhere close to agreeing with the advertised distance. Make sense?

What we - or at least I - am postulating is that many, maybe most tracks, are not as accurate as our certified road courses are. I am willing to bet there is more evidence of this out there that could be related by our fellow measurers.

This leads me to ask what the IAAF and USATF standards are for track measurements. In particular, what are the track distance measurement standards for accepting records for track performances? Obviously, many if not most tracks cannot produce a surveyor's certificate. So, how do we know whether they may be short or long, and by how much?

When we use one of our measuring methods, whether it is the Baumel method, or a Jones Counter application on a track, and the resulting measurement is several meters different than the nominal track distance, what if anything may we glean from this? How does this affect the validity of races conducted on this track? Most importantly, what does this imply, particularly if our methods expose a track to be SHORT of the advertised distance?

I'd like to hear from Andy or anyone else in the know what our criteria are for accepting performances that are published as records on these tracks. Maybe there is more here than meets the eye...
#42 • 11/3/16 @ 9:08 AM
I am curious about these measurements people have made that have come out to 403m or 397m. Were those done with the method that assumes circular curves? If so we're saying that the people who laid out the track made a mistake in getting the distance correct, but we are assuming that they still managed to create circular turns. I'm okay with this method if it is used just to confirm that a track is a standard length. If we are going to make the extraordinary claim that a track is not a standard distance we need to have a direct measurement of the track that makes no assumptions
#43 • 11/3/16 @ 9:25 AM
Lyman, I was too quick to make that comment as you posted. After talking to Katz, we are going to come up with a way to have consistency with measuring a Road race and track.

You are not as good as a professional surveyor as you say. It's more likely you and Jeff may have made a mistake. However, that is not a point to labor on.

I can tell you "Track" will not be on the certificate as we should never have certified a track. We should have certified a track as a Road Race.

I know this my upset some, but it will be explained clearly by the middle of next week.
#44 • 11/3/16 @ 9:39 AM
Good lively discussion guys. Thanks! I feel bad because all Gene wanted to do was simplify the road cert form.

I agree with Lyman's implication that we probably can not resolve the broader issues stirred up here within RRTC alone. An ideal solution might be for USATF to have the Track & Field equivalent of RRTC handle these things. Do we have a "TFTC"?

Here's what troubles me about this now: While trying to see if the Anchorage "The Dome" track ever had actually been 400 meters, I learned that the current operators are actually publishing the following:

"At 180,000 square feet, The Dome is officially the largest sports complex of its kind on the planet
... The Dome houses a 400-meter USA Track & Field certified track, ... and much more."

Yikes! Re the track: that's doubly wrong! I don't think there is such a thing as a "USATF Certified Track" and our guys didn't "certify the track", they only certified the distance of a lap and in so doing demonstrated that it was not 400 meters.

Well, there's David's proof that folks will misunderstand and abuse our efforts to convey the measured length of a lap.

I think it was a valuable and constructive service to cost-effectively deliver the one track parameter most runners were interested in. But, to preserve our good reputation, if we can't find a way to better distinguish between "certifying a track" and certifying the running length of a lap of the track, then perhaps we should exit this service.

Should we perhaps call it a "certified lap"? Would that prevent the abuse?

JJ
#45 • 11/3/16 @ 9:49 AM
Jeff,

David and I have a simple solution. So just wait till next week
#46 • 11/3/16 @ 10:28 AM
quote:
Originally posted by Gene Newman:
Lyman, I was too quick to make that comment as you posted. After talking to Katz, we are going to come up with a way to have consistency with measuring a Road race and track.

You are not as good as a professional surveyor as you say. It's more likely you and Jeff may have made a mistake. However, that is not a point to labor on.

I can tell you "Track" will not be on the certificate as we should never have certified a track. We should have certified a track as a Road Race.

I know this my upset some, but it will be explained clearly by the middle of next week.


Hah-ha, Gene. Show me where I am claiming to be a "professional surveyor", or how I implied this. If you actually read the post, you will see that I make no such claim. So, what compels you to make such an irrelevant statement?

Sure, Jeff or I could have made mistakes. Certainly, we have here two examples where track constructors have made mistakes. Might there be more?

Even Bob Thurston, with whom I measured this track, could have made a mistake. But - really? In my 35 years' experience and IMHO, Bob Thurston is as or more meticulous a measurer than anyone, Mr. Katz included. We steel tape measured both curves, measured the sides, the width in several places, employed the Baumel formula, then did it all over again. This took about 4 hours. After all of this, who here would speculate that the track constructor was more accurate than mathematician Bob?

Mark, thanks for bringing up this important topic. I conclude that we are now contemplating a new category of measurement - for a race that happens to be wholly conducted on a track - for which our road certification standards may be applied. This would avoid the entire thicket of "track certification", which is not our business. We would need to make careful calculations to determine the placement of the Start, Finish, and of the timing points. But it seems to me that this can be no more challenging to measure or to conduct a race for than a road race. We would clearly indicate that the "running course" is USATF certified, and that we make no claim as to the distance of a single track lap.

I am still curious about IAAF and USATF standards for acceptance of record performances on tracks. Are all of these records backed up by track survey certificates? In two out of two track measurements described in this thread, the tracks were measured to be different from their respective advertised distances. This does not give me confidence that most tracks are accurate.
#47 • 11/3/16 @ 12:07 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Lyman Jordan:
quote:
Originally posted by Gene Newman:
Lyman, I was too quick to make that comment as you posted. After talking to Katz, we are going to come up with a way to have consistency with measuring a Road race and track.

You are not as good as a professional surveyor as you say. It's more likely you and Jeff may have made a mistake. However, that is not a point to labor on.

I can tell you "Track" will not be on the certificate as we should never have certified a track. We should have certified a track as a Road Race.

I know this my upset some, but it will be explained clearly by the middle of next week.


Hah-ha, Gene. Show me where I am claiming to be a "professional surveyor", or how I implied this. If you actually read the post, you will see that I make no such claim. So, what compels you to make such an irrelevant statement?

Sure, Jeff or I could have made mistakes. Certainly, we have here two examples where track constructors have made mistakes. Might there be more?

Even Bob Thurston, with whom I measured this track, could have made a mistake. But - really? In my 35 years' experience and IMHO, Bob Thurston is as or more meticulous a measurer than anyone, Mr. Katz included. We steel tape measured both curves, measured the sides, the width in several places, made careful temperature adjustments of the tape, employed the Baumel formula, then did it all over again. This took about 4 hours. After all of this, who here would speculate that the track constructor was more accurate than mathematician Bob?

Mark, thanks for bringing up this important topic. I conclude that we are now contemplating a new category of measurement - for a race that happens to be wholly conducted on a track - for which our road certification standards may be applied. This would avoid the entire thicket of "track certification", which is not our business. We would need to make careful calculations to determine the placement of the Start, Finish, and of the timing points. But it seems to me that this can be no more challenging to measure or to conduct a race for than a road race. We would clearly indicate that the "running course" is USATF certified, and that we make no claim as to the distance of a single track lap.

I am still curious about IAAF and USATF standards for acceptance of record performances on tracks. Are all of these records backed up by track survey certificates? In two out of two track measurements described in this thread, the tracks were measured to be different from their respective advertised distances. This does not give me confidence that most tracks are accurate.
#48 • 11/3/16 @ 2:55 PM
Nothing more to say until next week
#49 • 11/5/16 @ 7:49 AM
Lyman, you steel-taped the turns, and used the Baumel method? It seems odd that you would steel tape the entire length of the track, and then also use a short-cut method.
#50 • 11/5/16 @ 12:39 PM
Mark, I missed my promotion to "professional surveyor". I thought I was only a measurer. Turns out, not only was I somehow promoted from measurer to surveyor, I am not as good a surveyor as I thought I was. So clearly, I was wrong and out of line.

Since Gene poured cold water on this lively and valuable topic that you started, I will just shut up now and not trouble poor Gene any more with my nettlesome questions or ideas.

The BB was fun while it lasted. Thanks for all that you do.
#51 • 11/8/16 @ 10:06 AM
For the record, I didn't start this discussion. I reposted the list of topics that will be discussed at the RRTC meeting in December, one thread per topic.
#52 • 11/11/16 @ 11:23 AM
Personally I like the idea of the RRTC Certifying track courses. Who is doing it now?

USATF/LDR records are kept for road and track races, as well as ultra and race-walk. RRTC is USATF/LDR’s technical advisor specifically for road racing. Can’t the RRTC scope be slightly broadened to include track courses or simply all LDR events?

The Application for Record - Road Race asks about the course certification. The Application for Record - Track Race asks about the Surveyor of the course (track). The RRTC is a natural agent to act as the Surveyor, especially in those cases the track surveyor is absence.

Assisting in the LDR track records process could easily be patterned on the Validation process for road races. Finally, the RRTC certainly has the technical knowledge how to measure road courses of all types of surfaces, which sometimes include tracks.
#53 • 11/11/16 @ 12:04 PM
Kevin, thanks for your questions and suggestions. Below is what the RRTC has decided to your post.

Your statement-- "Personally I like the idea of the RRTC Certifying track courses. Who is doing it now?" Kevin we don't certify tracks for track records. Andy Carr has stated that if it is a track record, then our certificate is not even looked at. One must present a certificate from a surveyor for the track record to be upheld.

Your statement-- "Can’t the RRTC scope be slightly broadened to include track courses or simply all LDR events?" The answer is no as must go by the IAAF standards, which means a surveyor must do it for a track event.

Your statement--"The RRTC is a natural agent to act as the Surveyor, especially in those cases the track surveyor is absence." The answere is no. Our method that Bob Baumel uses is good, but we don't have the expertise to place all the correct markings on the track for a track event.

Bob is going to make up a new certificate removing "Track" from the type of course. After much discussion, the officers have concluded we can only measure a track for a road race. To have "Track" as a check box is misleading. Hence, where it says "Type of Surface" and you have a road race on the track, then mark it 100% track.

The next question is what will be the acceptable method to measure a track for a road race. This will be discussed at our annual meeting.
#54 • 12/1/16 @ 2:37 PM
Several people in this thread have referred to the "Baumel method" of measuring a track. This refers to a document I wrote which is posted at www.usatf.org/Products---Servi.../Taping_a_Track.aspx and it's also linked from www.rrtc.net -- And now, to make it still easier to find, I've made the shortcut www.rrtc.net/taping_a_track which redirects to the same pdf file as the long URL above.

As one important point, the above document describes methods of measuring a track using steel tape, but says nothing about certifying it. I'll return to the question of (RRTC) certification of a track later. But first, let's discuss the accuracy obtainable using the methods in this document. And here I'll point out a fundamental difference between the measurements made by surveyors in officially surveying a track, and the measurements we make. The official survey measurements, following procedures specified by IAAF, are based on knowing the exact locations of the radius centers. Our task is rather different, as we're given an already constructed track, for which we don't know the radius center locations, and we want to determine a single number--the distance covered in running a lap of the track.

The document at www.rrtc.net/taping_a_track actually describes two methods. It states: "If curb is suitable, then tape circumference directly along outer edge of inner curb. If not, then use “Length-Width” method." I think we'd all agree that the first method (direct curb circumference taping) is highly accurate. In fact, its accuracy should match the accuracy obtainable in any careful steel taping. There was a time when many tracks, with either an asphalt or cinder running surface, had a permanent concrete curb that provided a good support for stretching a tape along. However, most tracks of that type have been replaced with more modern synthetic surface tracks, which don't have permanent curbs. Either they have no curb at all (typical of high school tracks), or they have a removable curb, which wouldn't provide suitable support for taping along, even when the curb is in place. Generally, the tracks with removable curbs are intended for higher level competition (e.g., university level or above), so a surveyor's certificate ought to be available. Thus, we're concerned mainly with uncurbed tracks, and the accuracy of "Length-Width" measurements for such tracks.

The Length-Width method described at www.rrtc.net/taping_a_track involves measuring two widths, W1 and W2. There is, however, a simpler Length-Width method that would involve measuring only one width (which might be measured along the 50-yard line if there's a football field marked on the infield). Here, if we've measured length L and width W, the circumference would be found by:
Circumference = 2*L + (pi - 2)*W
This ought to be accurate if the track has perfect geometry consisting of straightaways and semicircles at each end. The formula at www.rrtc.net/taping_a_track is obtained from the simple formula above by replacing W with the average of two width measurements, W1 and W2, in order to account for minor departures from perfect track geometry. As far as I know, the idea for doing this was originally due to Bob Letson. The widths W1 and W2 should be chosen near the ends of the straightaways, but clearly within the straightaways - don't waste time trying to locate junctions of straightaways and curves (if there's a football field marked on the infield, you might measure along the 5-yard lines).

How accurate is this refined Length-Width method (with the two widths, W1 and W2)? Back in 1986, Glen Lafarlette and I measured a track which had a permanent concrete curb, using both this Length-Width method and direct circumference taping. I wrote it up in the article "Measurement of Memorial High School Track, Tulsa, OK" in June 1986 Measurement News, which you can access at http://www.runscore.com/course...mentNews/017_86a.pdf (and if you don't know who Glen Lafarlette was, see www.rrtc.net/lafarlette_tribute.pdf). We found that, when using the same steel tape, the two methods agreed within one centimeter. This was true even though the track geometry obviously wasn't perfect - e.g., if you sighted down the straightaways, you could see that they weren't perfectly straight.

I compared Length-Width measurement and direct curb circumference taping again in 1989, on a different high school track (which also had permanent concrete curb). I don't seem to have preserved the data, but my recollection is that the agreement was again extremely close.

I conclude that the Length-Width measurement is very accurate, comparable to direct curb circumference taping, for tracks with the "standard" geometry of straightaways and semicircles at both ends.

Unfortunately, there are also "double bend" tracks, where each end of the track is a compound curve built with two different radii, resulting in a track with a somewhat more squarish shape. These are often used when it's desired to include a wider playing field, such as a soccer pitch, in the infield area. According to David Katz, it can be very difficult to tell by simple inspection that a track has double bend geometry instead of the standard geometry with semicircular ends. And if a track does have double bend geometry, the Length-Width method will significantly underestimate the track length.

The IAAF Track and Field Facilities Manual that can be downloaded from https://www.iaaf.org/download/...ition%20-%20Chapters includes diagrams (Figures 1.2.3b, 1.2.3c and 1.2.3d) showing dimensions of 400 meter tracks with three variations of the double bend geometry. From those dimensions, we can calculate that a Length-Width measurement would underestimate the track length by amounts ranging from around 5 to 10 meters.

From this, we conclude that, even if it can be difficult to distinguish a double bend track from a standard track by visual inspection, the difference should be readily apparent if we do a bike measurement (or other calibrated wheel measurement) in addition to Length-Width tape measurement, as those measurements will differ by at least 5 meters if it's a double bend track.

Now, my recommendations on certification where, based on previous discussion, it should be clear that we're certifying it as a "road" course, not a track.

First, since it's a road certification, we always have the option of measuring it by calibrated bike (or similar calibrated wheel method), just as we would measure any other road course. The only difference is that, if the track is uncurbed, we should measure/calculate it for an assumed running path 20 cm out from the inside edge (more on this later). As in any other bike measurement of a road course, the 1/1000 short course prevention factor would be used to ensure that the course is at least the stated distance.

If the track has a permanent curb suitable for direct taping of the curb circumference, this can provide greater accuracy and would allow use of a smaller SCPF (more on this later). Unfortunately, very few current tracks have a permanent curb of this type.

If the measurers wish to do Length-Width tape measurements, this can also provide greater accuracy than a wheel measurement, allowing use of a smaller SCPF. However, given the possibility that the track might have double bend geometry, we should never certify based only on Length-Width tape measurements. We should always require a wheel measurement in addition to the Length-Width tape measurement. Then, if the tape measurements and wheel measurements agree within a meter or so (for a 400 m track), we can take that as evidence that the track has standard geometry (with semicircular ends) and certify based on the tape measurements. If not, we'd have to certify based on the wheel measurements.

On use of SCPF: If certifying according to tape measurements (either direct curb taping or Length-Width method), the SCPF can be smaller than the 1/1000 used in normal road measurements. But an SCPF is definitely needed! All course certification and record keeping follows the principle that the course must not be shorter than advertised. When IAAF certifies a 400 m track, they specify a one-sided tolerance of 4 cm, meaning that its length must be between 400 m and 400.04 m (i.e., it can be up to 4 cm oversized but must not be shorter than 400 m). Thus, a track builder would aim for a measurement of about 400.02 m, to ensure it's within the window, given the accuracy of their measurements. RRTC has always used an SCPF for road course measurements, but curiously, when RRTC wrote certificates for tracks, we simply reported the raw results of tape measurements without any safety factor. This may have been done by analogy with calibration courses, but it's a false analogy. Nobody runs races on a calibration course. The only purpose of a calibration course is to calibrate a bike. Then, when we calibrate the bike, we apply the SCPF, so it gets incorporated in measured race courses. But people do run races on tracks, so when we certify a track (albeit as a "road" course), we must ensure it's at least the stated distance.

In a bike measurement, we apply the SCPF by multiplying the "constant" by 1.001. This has the effect of increasing the course length when laying out a course to a desired intended distance (such as 5 km). Or, when measuring the length of an existing fixed course, it reduces our stated result for the length of the course, below the result we would state without the SCPF. When measuring a track by steel tape, we must similarly reduce our stated result for the track length. But by how much?

With extreme care and ideal equipment, steel tape measurements can be accurate to better than 1 part in 10,000. Our measurements don't reach that standard, due to factors such as calibration error of the tapes and uncertainty in the temperatures used for temperature correction. It's often stated that "ordinary" steel taping should be good to 1 part in 5000. I'm not sure our measurements always reach even that standrd. But I'd be comfortable using a slightly bigger SCPF of 1/4000 for tape measurements of a track. Thus, for tape measurements of a 400 m track (by either Length-Width or direct circumference taping), the length written on the certificate should be 10 cm less than the original measurement result.

On 20 cm clearance for uncurbed tracks: Track rules state that the assumed running path is either 30 cm from the curb or 20 cm from a painted line defining an inside edge. For road course measuring, we normally specify only the 30 cm clearance. Historically, when Ted Corbitt sent letters in Sept 1982 introducing the SCPF and tighter SPR procedure, he said to measure 30 cm from curbs and 20 cm from uncurbed road edges (see one of Ted's letters at www.rrtc.net/SCPF_Adoption_1982.pdf). This was by analogy with the track rules. Then in 1985, when I was working with Ken Young and Pete Riegel on the first edition of Course Measurement Procedures, we decided it made no sense to keep specifying both 30 cm and 20 cm clearances for road measuring, especially since actual uncurbed road edges are nothing like painted lines on a track (they may be broken up, have dangerous drop-offs, etc.). But now, in the context of measuring on an uncurbed track, there is really a well-defined line marking the inside edge, and runners are really going to run closer than 30 cm from that line, so we really ought to measure/calculate at 20 cm. And, as pointed out previously in this thread, there's a huge difference between the lap distance at 20 cm and 30 cm -- about 63 cm, which is more than 1/1000 for a 400 m track.

As additional subtleties, even when measuring by bike, it's probably best to measure right at the inside edge, and then correct for the 20 cm clearance by calculation (by adding about 1.2566 m). To measure the proper path by bike, it's probably easier to walk the bike instead of riding it (Of course, if it's walked on the race course, it also needs to be walked on the calibration course). As one more point, if it's an uncurbed track, we'd need to decide exactly what defines the inside edge. If you want to use the painted line defining the inside edge of lane 1, that line would have to be coned during the race, and that would have to be written on the Certificate. The track surface probably extends some distance inside of that painted line. If the line won't be coned, we should assume that runners will use the entire track surface, so the assumed running path would be 20 cm out from the very inside edge of the available track surface.