I was catching up on some discussions I had missed and was reminded that Guido Brothers suggested back in October that cal courses might continue to live providing the original nails are still there at the endpoints.
It's a good idea. Has this been (or can it be) discussed?
Renewal of calibration courses
It's been discussed and I agree with you. To require a new measurement is make-work to no real purpose beyond bureaucracy.
Not true as we made a decision two years ago. How long does it really take to verify it's correct.
They expire like all courses after 10 years.
They expire like all courses after 10 years.
Here is the discussion from our 2012 meeting.
Lifetime of calibration courses: It had been suggested that calibration courses be exempted from our standard 10-year expiration policy, and should last as long as the nails remain in place. Discussion of this issue covered lots of things that can go wrong in trying to use a previously certified calibration course: Can we ever be sure that the nails currently in place are the original ones? What if a 300 meter calibration course is assumed to be 1000 feet, or vice versa? Gene Newman mentioned that in last year’s validation of the Olympic Trials course, the nails for one of the calibration courses looked wrong, and a steel tape check showed that course to be off by half a meter. Toni Youngman asserted that if you’re measuring in another city, you should always measure a calibration course yourself, even if it was certified by someone else. Jane Parks asked how much work it is to spend half an hour re-taping a calibration course once every 10 years. It was decided that calibration courses will continue to expire after 10 years.
Lifetime of calibration courses: It had been suggested that calibration courses be exempted from our standard 10-year expiration policy, and should last as long as the nails remain in place. Discussion of this issue covered lots of things that can go wrong in trying to use a previously certified calibration course: Can we ever be sure that the nails currently in place are the original ones? What if a 300 meter calibration course is assumed to be 1000 feet, or vice versa? Gene Newman mentioned that in last year’s validation of the Olympic Trials course, the nails for one of the calibration courses looked wrong, and a steel tape check showed that course to be off by half a meter. Toni Youngman asserted that if you’re measuring in another city, you should always measure a calibration course yourself, even if it was certified by someone else. Jane Parks asked how much work it is to spend half an hour re-taping a calibration course once every 10 years. It was decided that calibration courses will continue to expire after 10 years.
But wasn't it also decided that a single measurement that confirms the previously certified length is correct is good enough?
If you measure a cal course that was certified at 300m 10 years ago, and get 300.010m, it seems unnecessary to do a second measurement.
If you measure a cal course that was certified at 300m 10 years ago, and get 300.010m, it seems unnecessary to do a second measurement.
Mark, it could've treated the same as a course that has expired. I see no problem with that.